Inclusive projects
Part III: Preparing project briefs - best practice
6. Examples of best practice
6.1 Strategic briefs
6.1.1 The following list of access issues for inclusion within the project brief
is not intended to be exhaustive. The exact content and scope will be
dependent on the nature of the development.
6.1.2 The exact location of the access issues within the wider strategic
brief will also be dependent on the nature of the project and the
documentation. To maximise the impact of the access message, we
recommend that access related issues are grouped where possible.
6.1.3 This grouping into a self-contained sub document is often referred to
as an 'access statement'.
| Description | Access related example |
| Corporate needs and objectives |
'The relative inaccessibility of our retail unit has
resulted in the loss of customers to similar but
accessible stores.We have a commercial need to
maximise our customer base and thus our revenue.
In addition the existing access provisions within our
store may leave us vulnerable to civil action under
the Disability Discrimination Act 1995.
|
| A strategic statement of intent. This may be in the form of a mission statement |
'Our aim is to deliver well-designed and constructed
quality buildings that fulfil the principals of
functionality, build-quality, efficiency and
sustainability. To achieve this we must maximise the
access provisions within our store.
In doing this we will increase customer numbers,
increase the efficiency with which our existing
customers shop, reduce the risk of future civil action
under the Disability Discrimination Act 1995 and be
able to publicly and privately brand ourselves as a
morally and socially exemplar organisation'.
|
| A statement of key design and aesthetic aspirations, with guidance on relative priorities |
Our intention is to exceed the 'minimum' access
standards defined by Part M of the Building
Regulations and other mandatory documentation. Our
goal is to achieve best practice aspirational access
standards for all design, construction and operational
aspects of our new store'.
|
| Outline design and construction requirements |
Our high level design and construction requirements
are the full integration of the relevant best practice
access standards across the four areas collectively
representing high quality access:
- The urban environment - getting to the building
- The structure and fabric
- Information and equipment
- Our staff
|
| An assessment of options, supported by the results of feasibility studies |
Option 1: Refurbishment of the town-centre site - key considerations:
- Reduced site footprint demands that the multistorey configuration is retained
- Changes in levels and spaces has implications for way-finding and circulation reducing the efficiency of shopping
- Availability of public car parking reduced. Increased reliance placed on public transport
- Shorter journey
Option 2: New out of town development - key considerations:
- New site give opportunities for a 'from scratch' single storey design allowing high levels of access to be more easily achieved
- Ample parking and opportunities for extension of the local public transport infrastructure
- Longer journey development of any outline design where appropriate
- Contribution to and review of the contractors
emerging design
- On-site monitoring of construction activities
- Occupational review and assistance
|
| An assessment of procurement options and the implications of each |
The two procurement options currently under
consideration are 'Traditional' and 'Design and Build'.
If a Traditional route is chosen, then the
independently appointed Access Champion will
contribute to the design, construction and occupation
processes through independent and sequential
contributions to the process. These contributions can
be summarised as:
- Assistance in the development of the design and construction brief
- Contribution to and review of the emerging design
- On-site monitoring of construction activities
- Occupational review and assistance
If a Design and Build route is chosen, we will
maintain the involvement of an independently
appointed Access Champion throughout the lifetime
of the project.We will also make it a condition of the
contractor's design and build contract that they
appoint an appropriately skilled Access Champion
within their own design team.
The contributions of our own Access Champion can be summarised as:
- Detailed assistance in the development of the design and construction brief including the development of any outline design where
appropriate
- Contribution to and review of the contractors emerging design
- On-site monitoring of construction activities
- Occupational review and assistance
|
| Assessment of value for money and affordability |
Whilst designing to best practice standards may be
marginally more costly in bottom line terms, the
enhanced commercial, legal and moral benefits will
in turn enhance value for money.
|
| A project structure defining roles, responsibilities and the decision making process |
Whichever procurement route is chosen, we will
maintain the involvement of an independently
appointed Access Champion who contractually will
operate independently of either the client's design
team or the contractor's team.
The Access Champion will liase and integrate fully
with the clients team but shall provide independent
reports on access issues that shall be issued directly
to the clients as required.
|
| An assessment of adaptability for change and growth (future-proofing) |
The development shall be designed and constructed
in an inclusive manner allowing people with all forms
of disabilities to gain full access.
The scheme shall be adaptable to maintain high
quality access in the event of:
- Minor changes by the occupants in the way the
building is used on a day to day basis. This shall
include changes that are made for operational
reasons and for this reason full consultation with
the end users will be required
- More significant expansion or refurbishment
|
| Description | Access related example |
| A re-affirmation of corporate needs and objectives |
'The relative inaccessibility of our retail unit has
resulted in the loss of customers to similar but
accessible stores.We have a commercial need to
maximise our customer base and thus our revenue.
In addition the existing access provisions within our
store may leave us vulnerable to civil action under
the Disability Discrimination Act 1995.
|
| A reminder of the strategic statement of intent. This may be in the form of a mission statement |
'Our aim is to deliver well-designed and constructed
quality buildings that fulfil the principals of functionality,
build-quality, efficiency and sustainability. To achieve
this we must maximise the access provisions within
our store.
In doing this we will increase customer numbers,
increase the efficiency with which our existing
customers shop, remove the risk of future civil action
under the Disability Discrimination Act 1995 and be
able to publicly and privately brand ourselves as a
morally and socially exemplar organisation'.
|
| Enhanced details of the project structure including the procurement structure and the roles and responsibilities of the participants and the mechanics of the decision making and project assessment processes |
The Access Champion (traditional scenario)
Project structure:
- Directly appointed (i.e. is employed and paid) by the employer
- Reports to the employer on an independent basis
- Works with the design team and feeds day to day contributions directly to them.
Responsibilities:
- Refer to 'The role of the Access Champion'
- May or may not actually undertake design, depending on circumstances (may be limited to advising and critiquing designers work).
Decision making authority
- Design authority usually limited to reporting on designers proposals and construction observations.
|
| Enhanced details of the more specific design aspirations relating to particular functions or construction elements |
In respect of the provision for access within the new
building, it is our intention to design and construct to
best practice aspirational access standards for all
elements of our new store. In particular the guidance
set out in the following two documents are indicative
of the level of provision that we wish to achieve:
- British Standard 8300:2001 - The design of
buildings and their approaches to meet the needs
of disabled people
- Greenfield Council's 'Access and facilities for people
with disabilities - Supplementary Planning Guidance No.2'.
|
| Details of design standards, including prescriptive requirements where appropriate |
Parking
Parking shall be designed and constructed in
accordance with the following standards:
- British Standard 8300: 2001 -The Design of
buildings and their approaches to meet the
needs of disabled people - code of practice.
It shall comply generally with section 4 car parking,
setting down and garaging and specifically with the
following sections:
- 4.1.2 - provision of designated parking spaces
- 4.1.2.3 - Shopping, recreation and leisure facilities
- 4.1.3 0 - Off-street parking, garaging and enclosed parking
- 4.1.3.1 - Uncovered parking areas
- 4.1.3.2 - Design and layout of designated off street parking spaces (including figure 2).
Decorative finishes
Colour schemes shall be selected and specified in
accordance with the guidance contained within:
- 'A design guide for the use of colour and contrast to
improve the built environment for visually impaired
people' published by ICI Paints
Internal Steps
Internal steps shall be designed and constructed in
accordance with the Approved Document M (1999
edition) to the Building Regulations 1991 as follows:
The basic design shall meet Part M2 Section 2: Means
of access within buildings other than dwellings -
Internal Stairs 2.19 - 2.21 including diagram 12
- The design of the internal steps shall be enhanced
by designing the internal steps to also meet Part M2
Section 1: Means of access to and into buildings
other than dwellings - Stepped approach 1.24 a,b,h
and diagram 2
(N.B: Part M of the Building regulations is currently
under review. The focus of the revised Part M is likely
to be on access to and use of buildings by everyone
rather than by disabled people.)
|
| Description | Access related example |
| A review of the design and construction process |
The project structure generally operated
satisfactorily. However if the Access Champion had
been appointed independently, rather than as a sub
consultant to the architect, the design review process
by the Access Champion would have had a greater
transparency and clarity to the remainder of the
project team. In future we shall appoint Access
Champions independently.
|
| A review of the resultant structure and fabric measured against the original strategic and design and construction briefs |
Although the detailed design brief made general
reference to the needs of people with visual
impairments, their specific requirements were not
stipulated in detail. As a result we have a reception
desk that is back-lit by south-facing structural
glazing this casting the faces of the receptionists
into deep shadow on bright days. In future we need
to accurately specify the design requirements of all
disabled people.
|
| A review of the building's performance when measured against the original business need |
We have seen an increase in visitor numbers as a
result of our enhanced access provisions and this
has made a substantial contribution to our primary
business need of increasing revenue. In particular
improving the integration of our building with the
local transport infrastructure has had a major
impact. On future projects we should further
enhance investment in this particular area.
|
Published: 17 June 2003
[ Previous ] [ Contents ] [ Next ]
Top of page
|